The Cat Returns: A Whimsical Whisker Through Studio Ghibli’s Lesser-Known Gem

By SON HAK, Animation Enthusiast and Feline Fanatic

Released in 2002, The Cat Returns (Japanese: Neko no Ongaeshi, literally “The Cat’s Repayment”) is a delightful, often overlooked entry in Studio Ghibli’s illustrious catalog. Directed by Hiroyuki Morita in his directorial debut, this 75-minute anime fantasy adventure spins a surreal, lighthearted tale that stands apart from the studio’s more epic offerings like Spirited Away or Princess Mononoke. Born from a canceled theme park project and rooted in Aoi Hiiragi’s manga Baron: The Cat Returns, this film is a love letter to cat lovers, dreamers, and anyone who’s ever felt lost in the chaos of growing up. In this review, we’ll explore what makes The Cat Returns a unique gem, diving into its narrative, characters, visuals, themes, and cultural impact, while offering fresh insights into its quirky charm.

A Purr-fectly Peculiar Plot

The story follows Haru Yoshioka, a 17-year-old schoolgirl in modern Japan who’s struggling with the everyday trials of adolescence—clumsiness, self-doubt, and a crush that won’t quit. Her life takes a fantastical turn when she impulsively saves a cat from being hit by a truck. This isn’t just any cat, but Lune, the Prince of the Cat Kingdom. In gratitude, the Cat King (voiced with delicious flamboyance by Tetsurō Tanba in Japanese and Tim Curry in the English dub) showers Haru with bizarre gifts—think boxes of live mice and fields of catnip—before decreeing she must marry Lune and live in the Cat Kingdom.

Horrified at the prospect of becoming a feline bride, Haru seeks help from the mysterious Cat Bureau, a trio of unlikely heroes: the suave Baron Humbert von Gikkingen (Yoshihiko Hakamada/Cary Elwes), a dapper cat statuette come to life; Muta (Tetsu Watanabe/Peter Boyle), a grumpy, overweight feline with a penchant for snacks; and Toto, a crow who serves as the group’s aerial support. What ensues is a fast-paced adventure as Haru navigates the surreal Cat Kingdom, dodging sword-wielding cat guards, a manipulative king, and her own transformation into a cat. Along the way, she learns to embrace her inner strength and affirm her identity, guided by the Baron’s sage advice: “Nobody decides who I am but me.”

Unlike Studio Ghibli’s grand epics, The Cat Returns keeps things simple and playful, clocking in at a brisk 75 minutes. Its brevity is both a strength and a limitation—while the pacing is relentless and engaging, some character arcs and world-building feel rushed. Still, the film’s whimsical tone and Alice-in-Wonderland-esque absurdity make it a refreshing departure from the studio’s heavier fare.

Characters That Claw at Your Heart

Haru is the heart of the film, a relatable everygirl whose insecurities resonate with anyone who’s felt out of place. Her journey from self-doubt to confidence is subtle but empowering, making her a strong female lead without the need for grand heroics. Chizuru Ikewaki’s Japanese performance captures Haru’s vulnerability and growth, while Anne Hathaway’s English dub adds a warm, earnest charm.

The Baron, a fan-favorite from his cameo in Whisper of the Heart, steals the show with his charismatic, top-hat-wearing swagger. Voiced with debonair flair by Cary Elwes in the English dub, he’s the epitome of cool, with a touch of knightly honor that sparks Haru’s (and the audience’s) admiration. Muta, the grouchy, food-obsessed cat, provides comic relief with his deadpan insults and surprising loyalty. His backstory as a notorious fish-devouring criminal in the Cat Kingdom adds a hilarious layer to his curmudgeonly persona. Rounding out the trio, Toto the crow brings a grounded, no-nonsense energy, balancing the group’s dynamics.

The Cat King is a standout villain, not for menace but for his unhinged eccentricity. Tim Curry’s English performance is a riot, dripping with theatrical mischief as he schemes to keep Haru in his kingdom. Supporting characters like Yuki, a kind-hearted cat maiden, and Lune, the earnest prince, add depth to the Cat Kingdom, though their limited screen time leaves you wanting more.

Visuals and Sound: A Cozy, Catnip-Filled Dreamscape

While The Cat Returns doesn’t boast the lush, painterly visuals of Miyazaki’s masterpieces, its animation is charming and effective. The real-world scenes use muted oranges, yellows, and greens to create a warm, nostalgic vibe, while the Cat Kingdom bursts with surreal details—think towering castles, maze-like corridors, and a banquet hall where cats toss squids for entertainment. The film’s simpler art style, influenced by its origins as a planned 20-minute short, gives it a distinct, almost storybook-like feel compared to Ghibli’s more elaborate productions.

A standout visual sequence is the maze scene, where Haru, Baron, and Muta race through shifting walls pursued by the Cat King’s guards. The collapsing walls create a domino-like spectacle, blending tension with visual gags. Another highlight is the Cat King’s nighttime parade, a magical procession of lantern-carrying felines that feels both wondrous and faintly eerie.

Yuji Nomi’s score is a delightful mix of whimsical and regal tones, with 29 unique tracks that keep the short runtime audibly diverse. The Cat Bureau theme, with its soft, nostalgic melody, evokes Whisper of the Heart, while the Cat King’s parade features traditional bamboo instruments that amplify the scene’s otherworldly charm. Ayano Tsuji’s theme song, Kaze ni Naru (“Become the Wind”), is a breezy, uplifting closer that perfectly captures Haru’s newfound confidence.

Themes: Finding Your Inner Meow

At its core, The Cat Returns is about self-discovery and courage. Haru’s journey mirrors the universal struggle of adolescence—feeling pressured to conform while grappling with who you want to be. The Cat Kingdom, with its seductive pull to transform Haru into a cat, symbolizes the temptation to lose oneself to external expectations. The Baron’s guidance helps Haru reclaim her agency, delivering a timeless message: believe in yourself, and don’t let others define your path.

The film also subtly explores the harmony between humans and animals. Haru’s interactions with the cats highlight mutual respect, culminating in a story that celebrates individuality without demonizing the feline world. Unlike Spirited Away’s dense mythology, The Cat Returns keeps its themes accessible, making it ideal for younger audiences while still resonating with adults.

Critical Reception and Cultural Paw-print

The Cat Returns earned an 88% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes, with critics praising its charm and accessibility, though some noted its simplicity compared to Miyazaki’s works. Metacritic’s score of 70/100 reflects “generally favorable” reviews, with outlets like Variety calling it “catchy entertainment for kids and adults” and The Guardian noting its appeal to “cat people.” However, some critics, like Empire, felt the story lacked emotional depth or tension, making it less impactful than Ghibli’s heavyweights.

On platforms like Reddit, fans are divided. Some adore its lighthearted fun and cat-centric humor, with one user calling it “the funniest Ghibli film” for scenes like Lune dusting himself off like a human. Others see it as “mid-tier” Ghibli, citing its short runtime and lack of the studio’s signature emotional weight. Its origins as a TV movie explain its streamlined scope, but for many, its charm lies in its unpretentious joy.

The film was a commercial success, grossing $65 million worldwide and becoming Japan’s highest-grossing domestic film of 2002. It won the Excellence Prize at the 2002 Japan Media Arts Festival, cementing its place as a beloved, if underappreciated, Ghibli classic.

Why It’s Unique

The Cat Returns stands out for its playful irreverence and compact storytelling. Unlike Ghibli’s sprawling epics, it embraces a fairy-tale simplicity that feels like a bedtime story come to life. Its connection to Whisper of the Heart—through the Baron and Muta—adds a layer of meta-narrative charm, as if Haru’s adventure could be a story written by Shizuku from the earlier film. The film’s cat-centric world is a love letter to feline quirks, from their aloof arrogance to their surprising loyalty, making it a must-watch for cat lovers.

Morita’s directorial debut also sets it apart. As one of only a few Ghibli films not directed by Miyazaki or Isao Takahata, it carries a distinct voice—less poetic, more grounded, yet still infused with Ghibli’s magic. Its blend of humor, heart, and surrealism, paired with a stellar English voice cast (Anne Hathaway, Cary Elwes, Tim Curry), makes it a unique bridge between Japanese and Western sensibilities.

Paws and Reflect: Who’s It For?

The Cat Returns is a purr-fect fit for younger audiences (recommended for ages 3 and up due to mild fantasy violence) and anyone craving a light, fantastical escape. Its short runtime and slapstick humor make it an excellent family movie, though parents should note scenes of cartoonish violence (sword fights, a tower explosion) and Haru’s near-miss with a truck, which could be imitable. Cat lovers will revel in the film’s affectionate portrayal of feline behavior, while Ghibli fans will appreciate its ties to Whisper of the Heart.

If you’re expecting the emotional depth of Grave of the Fireflies or the visual grandeur of Howl’s Moving Castle, you might find The Cat Returns slight. But if you approach it as a playful, self-contained adventure, it’s a delightful romp that leaves you smiling. As one Letterboxd user humorously noted, “Disorganized schoolgirl has a sexual awakening at the hands of a gentleman dandy cat”—and somehow, that sums up the film’s quirky allure.

Final Verdict: A Feline Fantasy Worth Rediscovering

The Cat Returns may not be Studio Ghibli’s magnum opus, but its charm lies in its simplicity and heart. It’s a fast-paced, funny, and visually enchanting tale that celebrates self-confidence and the magic of everyday heroism. Whether you’re a cat person, an anime aficionado, or just in the mood for a feel-good adventure, this film is a hidden treasure in Ghibli’s catalog. So, grab a sunbeam, curl up, and let The Cat Returns whisk you away to a world where cats rule and courage reigns.

Rating: 4/5 Paws
Where to Watch: Stream on Max, rent on Fandango at Home, or buy the Blu-ray/DVD from GKIDS.
Pro Tip: Watch in Japanese with subtitles for the authentic experience, but don’t miss Tim Curry’s iconic Cat King in the English dub

---

Sources: This review draws on insights from Common Sense Media, Rotten Tomatoes, IMDb, Wikipedia, and other web resources, critically examined for accuracy and relevance.